Stalinism and the degeneration of the Soviet Union

lenin colour 720What is the balance sheet of the October Revolution and the great experiment in planned economy that followed it? What implications do they have for the future of humanity? And what conclusions should be drawn from them? The first observation ought to be self-evident. Whether you are in favour or against the October Revolution, there can be no doubt whatsoever that this single event changed the course of world history in an unprecedented way. The entire twentieth century was dominated by its consequences. 

We regard the October Revolution as the greatest single event in human history. Why do we say this? Because here for the first time, if we exclude that glorious but ephemeral event that was the Paris Commune, millions of ordinary men and women overthrew their exploiters, took their destiny in their own hands, and at least began the task of transforming society.

That this task, under specific conditions, was diverted along channels unforeseen by the leaders of the Revolution does not invalidate the ideas of the October Revolution, nor does it lessen the significance of the colossal gains made by the USSR for the 70 years that followed.

The enemies of socialism will reply scornfully that the experiment ended in failure. We reply in the words of that great philosopher Spinoza that our task is neither to weep nor to laugh but to understand.

It was not the degenerate Russian bourgeoisie, but the nationalised planned economy that dragged Russia into the modern era, building factories, roads and schools, educating men and women, creating brilliant scientists, building the army that defeated Hitler, and putting the first man into space.

Despite the crimes of the bureaucracy, the Soviet Union was rapidly transformed from a backward, semi-feudal economy into an advanced, modern industrial nation. In the end, however, the bureaucracy was not satisfied with the colossal wealth and privileges it had obtained through plundering the Soviet state. As Trotsky predicted, they passed over to the camp of capitalist restoration, transforming themselves from a parasitic caste to a ruling class.

– From the introduction to Russia: From Revolution to Counter-Revolution

(For a detailed analysis of the actual events in 1917 and afterwards, please visit our dedicated In Defence of October website.)

Title Created Date Author
Lies, damned lies and Netflix: the character assassination of Leon Trotsky 14 March 2019 Alan Woods and Josh Holroyd
Reassessing Leon Trotsky’s biography of Stalin: a book review by John Riddell 18 December 2018 John Riddell
Origins of Trotskyism 06 September 2018 Rob Sewell
50 years after the Prague Spring – what are the lessons for today? 22 August 2018 Ben Gliniecki
From emancipation to criminalisation: Stalinist persecution of homosexuals from 1934 13 April 2018 Fred Weston
Russia: How the Bureaucracy Seized Power ‒ part four: the bureaucratic counter-revolution 09 February 2018 George Collins
Russia: How the Bureaucracy Seized Power ‒ Part three: 'socialism in one country' 01 February 2018 George Collins
Russia: How the Bureaucracy Seized Power ‒ Part two: isolation and degeneration of the workers' state 04 January 2018 George Collins
Russia: How the Bureaucracy Seized Power ‒ Part one: The Russian working-class takes power 01 December 2017 George Collins
Top 10 lies about the Bolshevik Revolution 01 November 2017 Alex Grant
[Book] Russia: From Revolution to Counter-Revolution 10 October 2017 Ted Grant
The truth about Stalin and Trotsky: a reply to Boris Stremlin 10 July 2017 Alan Woods
[Video] In Defence of the Russian Revolution - Part two 17 February 2017 Alan Woods
[Video] In Defence of the Russian Revolution - Part one 03 February 2017 Alan Woods
What the Russian Revolution achieved and why it degenerated 27 January 2017 Alan Woods
Communists against Stalin: the massacre of a generation – Preface to the book 25 November 2016 Alan Woods
The Truth about Stalin - a Reply to the Morning Star 08 November 2016 Alan Woods
In Defence of Lenin 21 January 2014 Rob Sewell
[Video] The Russian Revolution: Triumph or Tragedy 07 November 2013 Marxist Student Federation
[Audio] The Rise and Fall of the Communist International 11 December 2012 Marie Frederiksen